In 1939, the year that sigmund freud died in london, the book was published. Derridas yerushalmi, yerushalmis freud ucla history. Concerning the highpriests preparations for the service of the day of atonement when the temple was in existence mishna. Saul lieberman, on the yerushalmi jerusalem, 1929, pp. Freud further suggests that moses led only his close followers into freedom during an unstable period in egyptian history and that his followers. Moses and monotheism by sigmund freud free book pdf. Yerushalmi berakhot the talmud of the land of israel. Sigmund freuds moses and monotheism published in 1939 by knopf is a collection three essays in which freud questions if moses is in fact jewish. The yerushalmi text that we have contains many corrupt passages. For those readers unfamiliar with freuds struggle to establish a pure science of psychoanalysis without seriously compromising his cultural identity, freuds moses is a more than adequate introduction. Freud once again returned to the story of moses and reflected on themes common to his early and late work. Yerushalmi presents the work as freud s psychoanalytic history of the jews, judaism, and the jewish psychehis attempt, under the shadow of nazism, to discover what has made the jews what they are. Open library is an initiative of the internet archive, a 501c3 nonprofit, building a digital library of internet sites and other cultural artifacts in digital form.
His scandalous and diycult book frequently has been viliwed and dismissed because freud claims that moses was not a hebrew but an egyptian, and he also claims that the jews murdered moses in the. Being a pioneer in the field of psychoanalysis, he set out to investigate the origins of the jewish people. A dictionary of the targumim, the talmud babli and yerushalmi, and the midrashic literature by jastrow, marcus. In his book, freud explains that the egyptian god aton was in fact the original god of moses. Apr 09, 2018 in moses and monotheism, his famous investigation of the origins of judaism, sigmund freud contends that moses was actually an egyptian, who taught monotheism to the jews who then murdered him and repressed the memory of this murder although traces of the crime are preserved in the bible and in the jewish psyche. Needless to say, he upset both jews and christians with his. Freud and the legacy of moses freuds last book, moses and monotheism, was published in during one of the darkest periods in jewish history. Aramaic language, dictionaries, english, hebrew language, talmudic hebrew. Seven days before the day of atonement the highpriest is to be removed from his house to the palhedrin chamber, and another highpriest is appointed to substitute him in case he become unfit for the service by becoming unclean. Analysis of moses and monotheism by sigmund freud essay. Rice tells of the geographic, intellectual, and religious journey that the freud family, like thousands of other jews, made out of the ghettos of eastern europe, and how the vicissitudes of this odyssey affected sigmund freud, his character, genius, and creativity. To the extent that this is derridas central mission.
The subject of this book is an attempt to delve into the origins of judaism and make sense of the story of exodus. In most editions of the yerushalmi, the talmud text is surrounded by the commentary of the 18thcentury rabbi, moses ben simeon margoliot, known as the pnai moshe. Sigmund freud, letter to sandor ferenczi, december 31, 1912 when freud referred to himself as being all savage in his letter to sandor ferenczi, he was. Among his most astonishing claims was that moses was not of jewish. In moses and monotheism, freud speculates that moses was not jewish, but actually born into ancient egyptian nobility and was perhaps a follower of akhenaten, an ancient egyptian monotheist. Moses and monotheism, freud s last major book and the only one specifically devoted to a jewish theme, has proved to be one of the most controversial and enigmatic works in the freudian canon.
According to freud, moses was egyptian and flourished during the reign of amenhotep iv later called akhenaton, who introduced monotheism as an unpopular and shortlived replacement for traditional egyptian religion. Berke 2008, the oceanic feeling, mysticism and kabbalah. In freuds moses a distinguished historian of the jews brings a new perspective to this puzzling work. His audacious talk of childhood sexuality, incest, and the need to overcome repression of sexual urges tantalized the public imagination. Moses margoliess commentary pene moshe more frequently than any other secondary source to help explain the meaning of technical, elliptical, or complex discussions. Yosef hayim yerushalmi may 20, 1932 december 8, 2009 was the salo wittmayer baron professor of jewish history, culture and society at columbia university, a position he held from 1980 to 2008.
A few weeks ago i came across a book by sigmund freud called moses and monotheism, his last completed book. Sigmund freud captured the american fancy when he paid his first visit to the united states. For those readers unfamiliar with freud s struggle to establish a pure science of psychoanalysis without seriously compromising his cultural identity, freud s moses is a more than adequate introduction. Full text of moses and monotheism internet archive. Hayim yerushalmis 1991 freuds moses and taken up in various ways by jacques derrida, jan assmann, richard bernstein, and edward said. Yerushalmi professor and director, center for israel and.
Yosef hayim yerushalmi argues that while attempts to psychoanalyze freud s text may be potentially fruitful, they must be preceded by a genuine effort to understand what freud consciously wanted to convey to his readers. Freud s moses by yosef hayim yerushalmi, 9780300057560, available at book depository with free delivery worldwide. During that time, a semitic tribe was enslaved in egypt. It shocked many of its readers because of freud s suggestion that moses was actually born into an egyptian household, rather than being born as a hebrew slave and merely raised in the egyptian royal household as a ward as recounted in. The pnai moshe clarifies and comments on the text of the yerushalmi, in much the same way that rashi rabbi shlomo ben yitzchak, 11th century explains and discusses the text. By the particularly close relationship to their god they acquired a. Hayim yerushalmi s 1991 freud s moses and taken up in various ways by jacques derrida, jan assmann, richard bernstein, and edward said. In the this remarkable book provides fascinating new insights into freuds intentions in writing moses and monotheismhis only work specifically. Moses introduced monotheism to the jews and gave the jews the rite of circumcision, which was also a feature of egyptian religion. Moses and monotheism, sigmund freud s last major work, would also turn out to. Moses and monotheism moses and monotheism was the last book that was ever written by sigmund freud. The selfconfidence of the jews, however, became through moses anchored in religion. Yerushalmi s account is both sensitive and scholarly.
The talmud yerushalmi also called the jerusalem or palestinian talmud, or the talmud of the land of israel, edited in the fourth and fifth centuries c. At his time, persecution and hatred for the jewish people was quite common. Jun 25, 2010 in moses and monotheism, freud speculates that moses was not jewish, but actually born into ancient egyptian nobility and was perhaps a follower of akhenaten, an ancient egyptian monotheist. Psychoanalysis of myth sigmund freud moses and monotheism. Moses, he reasons, was on the side of monotheism, but the polytheists had the upper hand. If anything, he proclaims it with even less reservation.
In freud s moses a distinguished historian of the jews brings a new perspective to this puzzling work. In the this remarkable book provides fascinating new insights into freud s intentions in writing moses and monotheismhis only work specifically. While much ink has been spilled in analyzing freuds work, few. Yerushalmis other admired works are from spanish court to italian ghetto, a 1971 study of the iberian jews, and freuds moses. Gods word sigmund freud captured the american fancy when he paid his first visit to the united states. An overview of the talmud yerushalmi the yeshiva world. Stattdessen ist freuds mann moses eine kulturtheoretische, in weiten. He presents the work as freuds psychoanalytic history of the jews, judaism, and the jewish psyche.
However, the god aton was not wholly accepted by the polytheistic priests of ancient egypt who had a deep connection to the people. Using both historical and philological analysis, yerushalmi offers new insights into freuds intentions in writing moses and monotheism. Published while he was alive, moses and monotheism1938, 3 freud is forced to save the law. The unexamined paradoxes of freuds moses and monotheism. Psychoanalysis of myth 4 freud s moses and monotheism. This remarkable book provides fascinating new insights into freud s intentions in writing moses and monotheismhis only work specifically devoted to a jewish theme. Moses and monotheism, freuds last major book and the only one specifically devoted to a jewish theme, has proved to be one of the most controversial and enigmatic works in the freudian canon. Among other things, freud claims in the book that moses was an egyptian, that he derived the notion of monotheism from egyptian concepts, and that after he introduced monotheism to the. Yosef hayim yerushalmi, a former professor of jewish history at columbia, in nyc, passed away in 2009. Open library is an open, editable library catalog, building towards a web page for every book ever published. In moses and monotheism, his famous investigation of the origins of judaism, sigmund freud contends that moses was actually an egyptian, who taught monotheism to the jews who then murdered him and repressed the memory of this murder although traces of the crime are preserved in the bible and in the jewish psyche.
Moses, through the ten plagues, defies the will of pharaoh and frees the israelites from slavery. Yerushalmis account is both sensitive and scholarly. Talmud yerushalmi the talmud yerushalmi, toras erets israel, has always stood in the imposing shadow of its younger brother, the talmud bavli. Freud thought that social life originated in unresolvable conflicts and hence that civilization was always vulnerable to radical disruptions. Among other things, freud claims in the book that moses was an egyptian, that he derived the notion of monotheism from egyptian concepts, and that after he introduced monotheism to the jews he was killed. Psychoanalysis of myth 4 freuds moses and monotheism. Freud and the legacy of moses freud s last book, moses and monotheism, was published in 1939 during one of the darkest periods in jewish history. Yerushalmi presents the work as freuds psychoanalytic history of the jews, judaism, and the jewish psychehis attempt, under the shadow of nazism, to discover what has made the jews what they are. Yerushalmi yomi calendar dafyomi advancement forum. Jul 28, 1991 yerushalmi presents the work as freud s psychoanalytic history of the jews, judaism, and the jewish psychehis attempt, under the shadow of nazism, to discover what has made the jews what they are. In moses and monotheism, which was published in 1939, the same year freud died, he boldly repeats his theory from totem and taboo, although having received substantial criticism for it, during the quartercentury since he presented it.
It shocked many of its readers because of freuds suggestion that moses was actually born into an egyptian household, rather than being born as a hebrew slave and merely raised in the egyptian royal household as a ward as. Freud announced that moses, the man who led the israelites out of egypt, was not a hebrew, but instead an egyptian prince and a follower of akhenaten the heretic pharaoh who had tried and pdf failed to force upon the egyptians his own form of monotheism. Yerushalmi berakhot the talmud of the land of israel tractate blessings translation, commentary, analytical outline, categories, synopsis and summary. Freuds moses by yosef hayim yerushalmi, 9780300057560, available at book depository with free delivery worldwide. Murder, exile, and the question of belonging, and richard j.
Like its better known eastern counterpart the babylonian talmud bavli the yerushalmi is an extensive literary work consisting of both halakhah and. While the bavli has become public property, the beis medrash in which halacha was determined and milchamta shel torah the war of torah learning was waged, the yerushalmi remained aloof and. As each subsequent manuscript was copied from the previous one, old errors were copied and new ones were added. Yosef yerushalmi, freud s moses i have been all omnipotence, all savage. Yosef hayim yerushalmi argues that while attempts to psychoanalyze freuds text may be potentially fruitful, they must be preceded by a genuine effort to understand what freud consciously wanted to convey to his readers. Judaism terminable and interminable yosef hayim yerushalmi. Freud and the legacy of moses freuds last book, moses and monotheism, was published in 1939 during one of the darkest periods in jewish history. Back in 1993, though, he wrote freud s moses, a discussion of sigmund freud s theory on the buried historically and psychoanalytically buried origins of monotheism.
1034 1010 1405 352 139 1241 114 170 436 1609 1161 567 998 1154 85 696 233 1238 1503 781 1283 556 911 1122 125 1441 1209 470 1377 389 1508 1097 904 368 536 525 1250 1285 1192 1139 567 166 20